The National Palace of Culture in Guatemala City under a cloudy sky, with a rain-soaked plaza in the foreground

Morales v. Treasury: Three Lessons for SDN Delisting Petitions

Free Case Evaluation
By Sanctions Law Center Editorial Team

In July 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia handed the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) another summary judgment win. In Martinez Morales v. U.S. Department of the Treasury, No. 24-cv-2519 (BAH) (D.D.C. July 24, 2026), Judge Beryl A. Howell upheld both a Global Magnitsky designation and OFAC’s later denial of the designated person’s petition for removal from the Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons List (SDN List).

The outcome is no surprise. Courts review OFAC’s sanctions decisions under the deferential arbitrary-and-capricious standard of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), and the opinion leans heavily on that deference. The case is still worth studying for anyone working on SDN List removal, because of the specific reasons OFAC gave for refusing to delist, all of which the court accepted. Each is a common basis for denying a delisting petition, and each is something a petitioner can address before OFAC decides.

Background: A Former Guatemalan Official’s Global Magnitsky Designation

On December 1, 2023, OFAC designated Luis Miguel Martinez Morales, a former Guatemalan government official, under Executive Order 13818. EO 13818 implements and builds on the Global Magnitsky Human Rights Accountability Act, and it authorizes sanctions on current or former government officials responsible for or complicit in corruption. Treasury alleged that in 2021 Martinez solicited large kickbacks to facilitate the Guatemalan government’s purchase of Russian Sputnik V vaccines.

Martinez petitioned OFAC for removal from the SDN List under 31 C.F.R. § 501.807. OFAC sent him two questionnaires, in February and June 2024, and he filed suit in federal court while the petition was still pending. On February 7, 2025, OFAC denied the petition, and Martinez amended his complaint to challenge the denial under the APA.

The court granted the government’s cross-motion for summary judgment. It rejected the argument that OFAC had withheld its reasoning, finding that the grounds for the decision appeared in the Federal Register and in OFAC’s denial letter, and that redactions protecting sensitive information did not keep Martinez from mounting a challenge. On the merits, the court deferred to OFAC’s evaluation of the record.

Martinez filed a notice of appeal on August 10, 2026, but later moved to dismiss it voluntarily. According to press reports, the D.C. Circuit granted the dismissal on October 20, 2026. The district court’s decision stands, and Martinez remains on the SDN List.

Lesson 1: Foreign Exoneration Is Not Conclusive

Guatemala’s anti-corruption agency had investigated Martinez and cleared him, and he was never charged with a crime. He relied on that outcome. OFAC’s response was that foreign legal outcomes do not bind U.S. sanctions determinations, and the court agreed.

The rule itself is not new. What deserves attention is how unevenly OFAC applies it. OFAC has traditionally said that exoneration in a foreign investigation or prosecution does not establish an insufficient basis for a designation. At the same time, it regularly relies on foreign investigations and prosecutions to find that a basis for designation exists or continues. Foreign proceedings count when they support the designation and are set aside when they don’t.

Whatever one thinks of that asymmetry, there are reasons behind it. A decision not to prosecute can reflect a high criminal standard of proof, limited resources, or prosecutorial discretion. It does not always mean investigators found the allegations untrue. OFAC needs far less than proof beyond a reasonable doubt to keep a designation in place, and it may have its own doubts about how independent a particular foreign process was.

This case also shows that a foreign outcome can change. In September 2026, Guatemala’s Attorney General confirmed that Martinez is under investigation for alleged money laundering and organized crime, and prosecutors have searched properties linked to his relatives and associates. He has not been charged. Still, a petition built mainly on a foreign clearance can lose its footing quickly when foreign authorities take a second look.

Treat foreign exoneration as supporting evidence, not as your argument:

  • Get the substance, not just the result. A closure decision that addresses the same transactions OFAC relied on, along with the evidence investigators reviewed, carries more weight than a certificate saying no charges were filed.
  • Tie it to OFAC’s stated basis. Show specifically how the foreign findings rebut the facts in the designation press release and the unclassified record OFAC provided.
  • Make the rest of the case. Pair the foreign outcome with a direct rebuttal of OFAC’s evidence or a showing of changed circumstances, so the petition doesn’t depend on a single document.

Lesson 2: Questionnaire Responses Can Decide the Case

OFAC cited stale financial disclosures and non-responsive answers to its questionnaires as evidence supporting the denial. Up-to-date and complete information is necessary to establish candor, and a lack of candor is often a basis for denying a delisting petition.

It’s easy to treat questionnaires as an administrative step on the way to a decision. They are evidence. When a court reviews a denial under the APA, it looks at the administrative record OFAC compiled, and the petitioner’s questionnaire answers make up much of that record. A judge applying deferential review won’t fill gaps in the petitioner’s favor. If the answers are incomplete or out of date, OFAC can conclude it cannot verify the petitioner’s claims, and a court will accept that conclusion.

Questionnaires also tend to arrive in rounds, and SDN removal often takes years. Financial information that was accurate when the petition was filed may be stale by the time OFAC sends its second questionnaire.

How to answer an OFAC questionnaire:

  • Answer the question asked. If a question doesn’t apply, say so and explain why. Don’t answer a different question or point OFAC to earlier submissions in general terms.
  • Keep financial disclosures current. Update asset, income, and corporate holdings information with each response, and supplement it if anything material changes while the petition is pending.
  • Address gaps and inconsistencies yourself. If an answer differs from a prior submission, a public record, or a court filing, explain the difference before OFAC finds it.
  • Back your answers with documents. Bank statements, corporate records, and resignation letters carry more weight than narrative.
  • Respond on time. OFAC names petitioner responsiveness as one of the factors that drives how long a petition takes.

Lesson 3: Remedial Steps Are Optional, but Expected

Under 31 C.F.R. § 501.807(a), a petitioner “may” propose remedial steps that it believes would negate the basis for designation. The regulation gives examples such as corporate reorganization and resignation from positions in a blocked entity. Martinez proposed none. OFAC faulted him for that, and the court sustained OFAC’s reasoning.

The regulation’s language is permissive, but OFAC’s practice is not. In recent years, failure to propose remedial measures has increasingly been a basis for denying delisting petitions. OFAC wants to know what has changed and what will keep the conduct behind the designation from happening again. A petition that is silent on that point invites OFAC to assume the answer is nothing.

This matters even when the main argument is that the designation was wrong from the start. Remedial proposals can be framed as forward-looking commitments without conceding the underlying allegations, and they give OFAC a path to removal that doesn’t require it to admit error. Depending on the facts, remedial steps for an individual designated for corruption might include:

  • Resigning from, or committing not to hold, government positions or roles with entities connected to the alleged conduct.
  • Divesting from businesses tied to the transactions OFAC identified.
  • Adopting compliance controls at companies the petitioner owns or controls.
  • Agreeing to reporting or certification requirements as a condition of removal.

As we explain in our guide to the grounds for SDN List removal, remedial steps supplement the two recognized grounds for removal, insufficient basis and changed circumstances. They don’t replace them. Morales shows that leaving them out entirely carries its own cost.

What Morales Means for Your SDN List Removal Strategy

Each of the three reasons OFAC gave turned on what Martinez put in the administrative record, or left out of it. Because review is deferential, the petition stage is where a delisting case is usually won or lost.

Litigation has a role. As the Zadornov delisting showed, a lawsuit can move a petition that has sat at OFAC for years. But a lawsuit can also prompt OFAC to decide on the record as it stands. Martinez’s petition was pending when he sued, and the denial came while the case was in court. If the record is thin, the decision you force may be a denial that a judge will uphold. Before filing suit, make sure the record is one you would want a judge to read.

Before submitting a petition or a questionnaire response, ask three questions:

  1. Does the petition rebut the evidence OFAC actually relied on, rather than leaning on a foreign legal outcome?
  2. Is every questionnaire answer complete, responsive, and current?
  3. Does the petition propose concrete remedial steps?

Frequently Asked Questions

If a foreign prosecutor or court clears me, will OFAC remove me from the SDN List?

Not automatically. OFAC does not treat foreign legal outcomes as binding, and Morales confirms that a court will accept that position. A foreign clearance can support a petition, especially when it addresses the same conduct OFAC relied on, but it should be one part of a broader rebuttal of OFAC’s evidence.

Do I have to propose remedial steps in an OFAC delisting petition?

The regulation says a petitioner “may” propose them, so they are not strictly required. In practice, OFAC increasingly treats the absence of any remedial proposal as a reason to deny, and Morales shows that a court will uphold a denial that relies in part on that reasoning.

Can I challenge OFAC’s denial of my delisting petition in court?

Yes. A denial can be challenged in federal court under the APA, typically in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Review is deferential and limited to the administrative record, so the quality of the petition and the questionnaire answers usually decides the outcome. Our OFAC litigation practice handles these challenges.

Work With an OFAC Lawyer on Your Delisting Petition

Sanctions Law Center is a Washington, DC firm focused on OFAC sanctions. We represent individuals and companies seeking removal from the SDN List, from the initial petition under 31 C.F.R. § 501.807 through questionnaire responses, remedial proposals, and, where necessary, federal litigation.

If you are preparing a petition, answering an OFAC questionnaire, or weighing a challenge to a denial, we can review your record and identify the gaps OFAC is likely to cite. Contact us to schedule a consultation.

This page is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should not act or rely on this information without seeking advice from qualified counsel about your specific facts.